Second-hand book sales surge due to LLMs needing training data, ironically given poor online content. This is a 'false consolation.' AI uses 'destructive scanning,' ripping spines to digitize books, annihilating physical copies and their unique serendipity. The author critically laments this destruction, highlighting the loss of old books' charm, distinctive smells, and the joy of discovering literary treasures. The intrinsic value of second-hand books, fostering personal connections and democratizing knowledge, is sacrificed for digital consumption, replacing authentic discovery.