This article explores AI's impact on short story writing, noting a study where AI-generated stories received higher engagement ratings than human ones. This, coupled with a literary prize controversy, prompts urgent questions about authenticity. The author emphasizes that human writing uniquely leaves a personal trace, reflecting life's imperfections and miracles. While AI can generate engaging content, the piece ultimately questions whether Large Language Models can ever truly replicate or surpass this inherent human essence and profound experience embedded in genuine human creativity.