Billboard's charts, designed for human competition, face an "existential emergency" with AI music's inclusion. The author criticizes Billboard's historical inconsistency, where human artists were excluded for technicalities, yet AI creations now feature. This undermines the charts' original intent of showcasing human artistic endeavor and fair competition. To maintain integrity, Billboard must apply its past discernment to exclude AI from its main rankings. The article argues that allowing AI blurs the line between human talent and generated abilities, urging Billboard to re-establish the crucial human element in its prestigious music charts.